ID evidence to Science & Technology Committee

Away from the Punch & Judy sagas of the week, in a quiet corner of the Commons heard evidence about how well government listens to scientific evidence. Jerry Fishenden spoke about ID cards. As he says

the ID cards consultation to date has been focused more on the procurement process than the business requirements and technology issues. The Home Office team expressed a desire not to stifle innovation by getting into the specifics of potential architectures. But I think it would be really useful to see a UK government study into the risks, feasibility and comparative merits of centralised versus decentralised identity systems in terms of systems reliability theory, or modern computer security concepts (including the widespread contemporary experience of large scale data breaches, social engineering and phishing attacks).

- given the fastest growth in ID fraud is online (through for example phishing attacks), it was unclear how the ID card would work in online scenarios (would it default for example to just chip and PIN?). And given that the delivery of online public services is a key part of the Transformational Government agenda, this is clearly an area in which a well-designed ID card could yield major benefits and tie in well with other identity initiatives including across health, local and central government and the private sector

- some concerns arose from the limited number of publicly available scenarios of how the ID card could be used in practice. And of those available, there are potential issues with their descriptions of the card’s usage in practice. For example, the scenario here indicates that the ID card will disclose your date of birth to any third party that needs proof of age entitlement (eg to buy alcohol or to get an old age pensioner discount). However, I believe this is not good practice based on our experiences with ID fraud. All that needs to be revealed in such a situation is that the person is over 18 or over 60/65. Neither their date of birth or age needs to be revealed. In fact, handing over personal information such as date of birth to anyone who requests sight of an ID card could generate vulnerabilities elsewhere: for example, telephone banking uses date of birth as one of the ‘secrets’ to prove who you are when you phone up. We need to be very careful that the ID card does not add to any potential identity fraud issues when there is a great opportunity for it to help enhance our privacy, as Dave Birch indicated in his evidence.

Let’s hope the new Home Secretary listens to scientific evidence and is not prone to groupthink.

Published by William Heath on 05/05/06 at 1:06pm

Comments

Full audio of this session is currently online at: http://www.parliamentlive.tv/Asx.aspx?content=content&meta=<STARTTIME Value="00:01:35"/><DURATION Value="01:50:33"/>&stream=parliament/00004684.wma&isParl=False

Reply by Jerry Fishenden on 05/05/06 at 3:23 pm
The proponent of iris scans sounded surprisingly sure of their accuracy and practicality.

But, after hearing that evidence: How can the ID Project continue in its present form?

Reply by Richard S on 05/07/06 at 12:00 am

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.

Next entry: ID: Bangladeshi bigwigs do it on the cheap

Previous entry: Dance of the intellectual pygmies, part 2

Ideal Government

Let's say what we want from e-enabled government. Let's observe government first-hand. Let's say "Wouldn't It Be Better If" (WIBBI). Become an ethnographer of bureaucracy today! It beats getting frustrated with public services.

Comment

Anyone is free to comment. Or mail with an article if you want to be an author. I'll post it up and send you a password. This whole thing is supported by Kable.

Authors

Member List

Sign up for new articles

ID evidence to Science & Technology Committee

Comments

Ideal Government

Categories

Comment

Authors

Sign up for new articles

Copyright

Designed by...

Statistics

ID evidence to Science & Technology Committee

Comments

Ideal Government

Categories

Comment

Sponsor

Authors

Sign up for new articles

Copyright

Designed by...

Statistics