Last summer I applied for Job Seekers Allowance in Birkenhead. I dare say I as the first person ever to answer ”Praxeologist” under the type of job I was looking for. Needless to say there was no suitable work, and I was actively encouraged to claim the income based allowance.

I was not intending to “live off the dole”, but was in a vulnerable financial position and felt it was fair game. I would have been willing to work in any job, but my advisor encouraged me to not take anything that wasn’t in the sphere of my qualifications: economics.

At the time, I was spending the summer at home in between study in the USA. I was told that I was therefore be ineligible for benefits because my academic funding should cover the summer.

WIBBI: The Dept. of Education and Skills correspondended with the Dept. of Work and Pensions?
For 10 months of the year I fund myself to get an education abroad, meaning that in 3-5 years time I’ll return to the UK with higher qualifications, and consequently pay more tax. Shouldn’t the DES encourage this from students? And if so, why should the DWP discourage it?

I would also be denied income support because I had moved in with my girlfriend. I did this because I could no longer afford to pay rent for my own place, and we thought we’d save money by sharing bills. This decision, however, meant that by common law we were a married couple.

WIBBI: The Dept. of Work and Pensions was compatible with the Inland Revenue?
To hear that her kind effort to reduce my outgoings invalidated any support from the state, at the very least I expected symmetry. If we were married in the eyes of the DWP, then surely we’d be married in the eyes of the IR? Alas not. My girlfriend could not claim married couple allowance, or any other tax credit for living with me.

There are three frustrations that linger with me following this episode. Firstly, each inconsistency increases the short term financial position of the govt, and decreases mine. This is why it feels unfair. Secondly, each inconsistency decreases the prospects of me developing into a qualified and richer tax payer. There is a lack of farsight that should be willing to invest in education. Finally, the story only has a happy ending because my parents happen to be able to support me.
If I were from a poor family, the inconsistencies between the various departments would have made me become elligible for income support, and for a very long time.

Wrap up...

Sponsor

Kable Ltd

Authors with password: click here to post

BLOGS & CRITICAL FRIENDS
Action on Rights for Children
Big Opt-Out
Dave's public sector blogs
David Osimo
David Milliband
DFID bloggers
FIPR
FutureGov
Ian Brown
Jeff Jonas, IBM
Jerry Fishenden
Kim Cameron, MS
Light blue touchpaper
Matthew Somerville
NHS23
No2ID
Obama team blog
Public strategist
Richard Allan
Robin Wilton, Sun
Sam Smith
Schneier
Spy blog
Toby Stevens/CW
Verified Voting
Whitehall Webby

PERTINENT ART
ACLU privacy pizza
Very model of a notional identity
Swizz of the cards
Handelsman: NSA wiretaps
Handelsman: US spying
Wearcam
Googlezon
Three dead trolls
Stefanos Pantagis

ESSENTIALS

Cluetrain Manifesto
RAE Dilemmas of Privacy
NCC Playlist for public services
Sousveillance
Stefan Brands' book summary
Ross Anderson book

Engelbart Mother of all demos
OTHER ID/SECURITY
ID theft spy
Planet Identity
Pledgebank for refuseniks
Home Office ID cards
Ann Cavoukian, Ontario

MYSOCIETY & SAM'S STUFF
MySociety/
They work for you
Fax your MP
DirectionlessGov
Comment on This
Place-O-Pedia

...and the original
Stand ID card campaign

OUR 2005 MAPS MASHUPS WINNERS
Plymouth Schools
Ben's UK speed cameras
5-day weather forecast
House sale prices
g-Traffic info

More Google maps mashups:
Googlemapsmania blog


Old stuff
RSS in government blog
Stefan Brands old blog